What isn’t good for chips isn’t good for taxpayers
Now that we’ve finished voting, it’s time for politicians to show us whether they actually intend to follow through on their promises to cut taxes and spending.
A plan they’ll undoubtedly never mention would be a win-win. It would reduce most government payrolls by 6.2% while increasing most public employees’ paychecks by the same amount.
That’s right. Taxpayers would save 6.2%, but workers would get 6.2% more. And not a single government service would be cut.
It sounds like a trick, but the only magic required would be for politicians at all levels to cooperate and do what they promised.
In Kansas, nearly all government workers double dip. They contribute to more than one retirement system in hope of someday qualifying for something most taxpayers don’t get — double pensions.
For many years, workers didn’t benefit that much from double dipping. A Social Security provision called windfall elimination reduced benefits by whatever other government pensions they received. But that provision has been gutted, allowing double-dipping to go on virtually unchecked.
Government workers and the entities that employ them typically each contribute 6.2% of the employees’ salaries to Social Security. Most government workers also contribute something like 7.18% to the KPERS retirement system.
In return, their employers (we, the taxpayers) contribute even more. Not only do we pay a matching 6.2% to Social Security, we also pay larger sums to KPERS. The amount starts at 9.44%. It swells to 11.32% for school workers and to 24.02% for workers under KPERS’ police and fire plan. In some cases, it can rise to as much as 30%.
But KPERS is what’s known as a “qualifying plan.” It isn’t legally necessary to contribute to Social Security if someone is covered by KPERS.
In fact, many states don’t. Neither do private companies like railroads, which have their own qualifying plans. Even many agencies in Kansas don’t. Most state troopers and KBI agents, for example, don’t pay into Social Security, and the state doesn’t have to kick in on their behalf.
But local governments are required under state law to enroll most employees in both, and irrevocable federal contracts require them to continue contributing once they start.
Bureaucrats will tell you that’s why the tax-cutting plan won’t work. It’s against the law. But laws can be changed. That’s why we have elections, to vote for people who can change laws.
Now that windfall provisions, designed to keep Social Security solvent, have been eliminated, it’s time to close the giant loophole that allows public employees to double dip and eventually drain the Social Security trust.
It’s also time to eliminate an unfunded mandate the legislature imposed on local units by requiring them to needlessly pay Social Security while exempting state agencies like the highway patrol and KBI.
While we’re at it, we might also look at other generous benefits granted to public workers. State law, for example, requires local units of government to contribute an additional 1% for death and disability insurance — again, something most taxpayers don’t get for free from their employers, particularly if they are self-employed.
Government workers also tend to receive far more generous health insurance than most private companies offer — if, in fact, they offer any at all.
Yet government workers are always clamoring for their base pay to be competitive with pay in private enterprise. Not only are their pay rates often higher and their time off and holidays more extensive, the pension and insurance benefits they receive are astronomically better.
This doesn’t involve just courthouse and city hall workers. One of the prime reasons for the U.S. Postal Service being in such a mess and constantly increasing rates is the huge pension liability it has incurred.
None of this boils down to a sexy Election Day slogan, but do the math. Many mills on our property taxes are directly attributable to excessive benefits such as these.
If our newly elected politicians really want to follow through on their campaign promises, they need to at least look at blotting up some of the red budgetary ink flowing through all these pension, insurance, and time-off loopholes for government workers — including themselves.
— ERIC MEYER